Is beer good for kidney stone removal? - #11852
I am really confused about my situation right now. A couple of weeks ago, I was at the ER with severe pain in my side, and after a million tests, they told me I have kidney stones. Anyway, they gave me some medication for the pain and told me to drink a lot of water, which I do, but now I'm wondering about something else! My friends keep saying that is beer good for kidney stone removal, and honestly, I’m skeptical. I mean, I thought alcohol wasn't great for health in general, but then they claimed that some studies say beer can actually help! Like, how does that even make sense? Are they just saying that because they enjoy beer? I did a bit of Googling and found mixed info. I asked my doctor but she was kinda vague, not really addressing the is beer good for kidney stone removal question directly. I heard something about how beer might help with hydration and urination, which sounds like it could help, right? Just wondering if anyone here has actually looked into this or even tried beer while dealing with kidney stones. Do you think is beer good for kidney stone removal or should I just stick to water? I’m really unsure and I want to do what’s best for my health. Any thoughts?
100% Anonymously
No sign-up needed.

Doctors’ responses
Drinking beer as a potential remedy for kidney stones might be an appealing thought among your friends, but it’s not a medically recommended approach. The theory comes from the idea that beer, being a diuretic, can increase urination which may help to flush out small stones. However, alcohol can also lead to dehydration, particularly if consumed in large amounts, which is counterproductive when dealing with kidney stones. Dehydration is a major contributing factor in stone formation, so the priority should be maintaining proper hydration with water rather than alcohol.
Additionally, there’s no concrete evidence from well-conducted scientific studies that shows that beer can assist in the removal of kidney stones. Drinking water should remain the primary recommendation for helping pass stones, as it’s generally effective and doesn’t pose the health risks that alcohol does. You’re also more likely to get balanced advice from your healthcare provider, who considers your overall health and condition when making recommendations.
Certain types of stones, like calcium oxalate stones, can be influenced by diet to an extent as well. It might be beneficial to reduce intake of things like salt, animal protein, and foods high in oxalate — but these changes should be done under medical guidance, considering any other health issues you might have. Follow-up with your healthcare provider is important if you experience persistent pain, have blood in your urine, or notice any fever or infection signs. In severe cases, medical procedures might be necessary, so keeping your doctor informed about your symptoms is key. Stick to water, and perhaps discuss dietary options with a healthcare provider or a registered dietitian to manage kidney stones effectively and prevent recurrence.
100% Anonymously
Get expert answers anytime, completely confidential. No sign-up needed.
About our doctors
Only qualified doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.