is gur better than sugar - #22904
I am really confused about sweeteners and need some clarity. I’ve been trying to eat healthier, and my friend told me that gur is better than sugar. I mean, I grew up with sugar being the go-to sweetener for everything, right? But now I hear gur is more natural and less processed. I looked online and found some claims saying gur is better than sugar cause it's got vitamins and minerals—like iron and calcium—but how much can that really matter? I started using gur in my tea, and honestly, it tastes kinda nice, but then I freaked out because I wondered if it still has the same calorie count as sugar?? Like, is gur better than sugar when it comes to weight loss or energy levels? I’ve also heard that it might help with digestion; is that true? My aunt says gur is better than sugar for overall health and that if you can use it, you should totally switch. But then, can I really trust that? What do all you docs think? Is gur better than sugar, or is it just another trendy health thing? Should I ditch the sugar altogether or keep mixing it up? I just need some solid advice here!
100% Anonymously
No sign-up needed.

Doctors' responses
Switching from sugar to gur, also known as jaggery, is a decision that has its pros and cons, dependent on your specific health goals and circumstances. Gur is less processed than the refined white sugar, this means it retains more of the natural nutrients found in cane juice, including small amounts of iron, calcium, and potassium. These micronutrients might be beneficial if you need additional sources of these elements, but the quantities are relatively small and should not be relied upon as a primary source. In terms of calorie content, gur is similar to sugar, so when it comes to weight management, the difference is negligible. Both contain about 4 calories per gram, so you’ll need to monitor your overall calorie intake regardless of the sweetener you choose.
There are claims about gur aiding digestion due to its mineral content and being less refined, which might be reassuring for those interested in more natural options. However, there’s limited scientific evidence supporting claims it significantly enhances digestion or energy levels compared to sugar. While gur might be marginally better due to less processing and micronutrients, it’s still important to consume it in moderation to avoid high caloric intake.
For someone aiming to lose weight or manage energy levels, the focus should remain on overall balanced nutrition patterns such as controlling portion sizes, minimizing intake of added sugars, whether that’s from sugar, gur, honey, or any other sweetener. If you’re considering switching for health improvements, the change should align with an overall healthier lifestyle that includes a balanced diet and regular physical activity. Ultimately, if you enjoy using gur and it fits into your dietary goals, feel free to include it as part of a varied diet, but don’t expect it to dramatically alter health outcomes just by itself. If you have any particular health considerations, like diabetes or dietary restrictions, it’s advisable to consult with a healthcare provider who understands your medical history for tailored advice.
100% Anonymously
Get expert answers anytime, completely confidential. No sign-up needed.
About our doctors
Only qualified doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.