Hello dear See as per clinical history it seems presence of fracture Fortunately there is good locomotion Less bleeding and post operative trauma It will require Conservative treatment Surgery or knee replacement therapy of recommended by orthopedic surgeon Limb motion Gait analysis Physiotherapy exercises must Kindly consider below factors for good prognosis Age Locomotive movement Healing potential Please share the result with orthopedic surgeon in person for better clarity There may be requirement of Ct scan knee USG knee joint Mri CBC Esr Regards
How to know if my father needs surgery for a left hip injury after an accident? - #29778
My father met with an accident on Friday he has a left hip injury should we go for surgery or not I have the scan report
What specific findings did the scan report show?:
- FractureHow severe is your father's pain on a scale of 1 to 10?:
- 1-3 (mild)Is your father able to move his leg or bear weight on it?:
- Yes, with some painHas he experienced any swelling or bruising around the hip area?:
- Yes, significant swellingWhat other symptoms has he experienced since the accident?:
- None of the aboveHas he had any previous hip injuries or surgeries?:
- No, first injuryHow old is your father?:
- 50-65100% Anonymously
No sign-up needed.

Doctors' responses
Hello
This is a significant fracture of the hip socket, and while the displacement is described as mild, the fact that it is comminuted makes it more complex. Your father should be seen as soon as possible by an orthopedic or trauma surgeon, because many of these fractures need surgical fixation to restore the joint surface properly. If the joint alignment is still good, doctors may choose non-surgical management with strict bed rest, traction in some cases, and absolutely no weight bearing for several weeks.
For now, he should avoid standing or walking on that side, keep movements minimal, continue prescribed pain medications, and watch for increasing pain, swelling, numbness, or fever. Recovery usually takes a few months, and proper treatment is important to reduce the risk of long-term complications like hip stiffness, arthritis, or difficulty walking later.
Take care
100% Anonymously
Get expert answers anytime, completely confidential. No sign-up needed.
About our doctors
Only qualified doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.