Kidney stone beer - #11755
I am really frustrated and confused right now. A few weeks ago, I started feeling this pain in my lower back and side, like a dull ache that became super sharp, and turns out I have a kidney stone—not the news I hoped for, honestly! My doctor suggested some treatment options, but then, out of nowhere, my buddy said something kinda odd about drinking beer — he mentioned something about kidney stone beer and how some people believe it helps. Like, is that a real thing? I can't help but wonder if kidney stone beer actually makes a difference, or is it just a myth? I mean, I know my doctor said staying hydrated is key, and I’ve been guzzling water like it’s my new hobby, haha. But now I'm far more curious about this beer thing. Like, does drinking beer really create problems? Would it make the kidney stone situation worse, or is there any evidence that could make things better? I heard it could help break down the stones, but I thought alcohol could dehydrate you? Ugh, it’s so contradicting! Anyway, I'm in this weird in-between place where I've got this pain and now I'm thinking about this kidney stone beer thing, but I don’t wanna mess anything up! Should I even be thinking about beer while dealing with this? Or is it better to steer clear? Would love to hear any advice, thanks!
100% Anonymously
No sign-up needed.

Doctors’ responses
It can be confusing when you hear mixed messages, particularly with something as discomforting as a kidney stone. Let’s break down the beer question. Historically, some people have suggested that drinking beer might help in managing kidney stones due to its diuretic properties — that is, beer can cause you to urinate more frequently, which might, in theory, help pass a stone. However, the science doesn’t strongly support beer as a treatment for kidney stones. Beer contains alcohol, and alcohol might lead to dehydration if consumed in excess, counteracting the benefits of increased urination and potentially making kidney stones worse. Generally, increasing your fluid intake with non-alcoholic fluids, particularly water, is the best strategy for helping to flush out the stones.
Your focus should be on consuming plenty of water throughout the day as you’ve been doing. This helps ensure that your urine stays diluted, which can aid in preventing stone formation and assist in passing any current stones. Drinking citrus beverages like lemonade, without added sugar, can also be helpful, as citrate compounds can deter stone formation. Regarding beer, occasional consumption might not significantly alter your health situation, provided that it’s done in moderation and doesn’t replace essential hydration from water or lead to dehydration. However, alcohol can also interact with any medications you might be using and should be consumed cautiously if recommended at all.
Another important aspect to monitor is your diet. Reducing intake of salt and animal protein can also help, based upon the specific type of stones you have, so dietary adjustments might be a part of your treatment plan too. Ensure you discuss anything you intake, including beer, with your healthcare provider to make sure it aligns with your overall health needs and treatment plan. If you feel serious symptoms or suspect any complications, reach out to your healthcare provider. They can provide more precise guidance on lifestyle factors that could influence your condition.
100% Anonymously
Get expert answers anytime, completely confidential. No sign-up needed.
About our doctors
Only qualified doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.